Skip to main content
Crypto News Week

Crypto markets, protocols and policy

SEC staff clarify when crypto voters count as a controlling group

SEC staff added three crypto FAQ answers on Nov. 2, saying unaffiliated governance voters generally are not a controlling group without separate coordination.

The Crypto News Week Editors3 min read

SEC staff clarify when crypto voters count as a controlling group

Three new answers from SEC Corporation Finance staff clarify when crypto governance voters may count as a “group” with control of a network. Added to the SEC’s crypto FAQ on Nov. 2, they address coordination among voters, governance housed in foundations and powers that can make an entity a central party.

The guidance gives you a clearer test for shared governance, but it does not settle how any specific network or token is classified.

When do governance voters count as a group?

Staff say participants in a functional crypto system’s broad-based governance generally will not be considered a group if they are unaffiliated and have no separate agreement or understanding to act together. The SEC’s FAQ says that includes coordination through delegation, while distinguishing it from participation in the governance system itself.

The answer is the same when governance is part of an organization, association or foundation and participation depends on holding the network’s native asset. But staff say the question remains a facts-and-circumstances determination. Even if voters form a group, they count as a central party only if they have operational, economic or voting control of the system.

The FAQ describes broad-based governance as transparent, rules-based and “wide and diverse.” Proposals, deliberations, voting and outcomes must be publicly accessible in a timely way; decision-making must follow procedures that no single stakeholder or coordinated group can change unilaterally outside those procedures. Power also must not be concentrated among affiliated or coordinated stakeholders, including through delegation.

What powers can make an entity a central party?

Staff say a central party oversees participation when it can control access to a crypto system at the protocol, validator or user level. The FAQ gives examples of unilateral authority to grant or limit access, change voting processes, choose who can validate transactions, or modify code, reverse transactions or revoke access.

A system generally would not have a central party overseeing participation if material operations run automatically under rules-based code. The same can apply when discretionary decisions are made solely through broad-based governance, provided its participants are not themselves a central party. A foundation could still qualify if it controls another system, such as by setting operating parameters for applications deployed on the network.

Does this settle a token’s regulatory status?

No. As Unchained reported, the FAQ does not name a project or declare any token a digital commodity or non-security. The SEC page says the answers are views of Division of Corporation Finance staff, have not been approved or disapproved by the Commission, and have no legal force or effect.

The answer about governance groups applies only to the digital commodity discussion in Section III of the SEC’s interpretive release. The agency says it has no relevance or application to other federal securities-law provisions that address groups, including the Exchange Act definition of an exchange.

References